Odd Fellow’s is a small-batch ice cream company with a creativity problem. Since opening their first Odd Fellows Ice Cream shop in Brooklyn in 2013, tthey have concocted more than 500 wacky and weird flavors alongside reimagined and improved classics. Odd Fellow’s ice cream is like driving 31 in a 25, honking the horn the entire time.

In 2011, Mohan Kumar had a problem. He needed to find a fix for his wife Holiday, whose strange pregnancy cravings included savory ice cream she couldn’t find on grocery shelves. He mentioned this to his friend Chef Sam, who whipped up a few quarts of pretzel ice cream. Holiday loved it so much that the trio decided to start an ice cream empire, with their first kingdom in Williamsburg.

Acclaimed pastry chef Sam Mason is the wizard behind all of OddFellows’ creations. Best known as the opening pastry chef at Michelin-starred WD~50, Chef Sam is a James Beard Award nominee.

Made in Williamsburg, NY

Founded by Mohan Kumar and Sam Mason in 2011.

Buy here.

Seasonal Ice Cream